Payment of eviction indemnity

damages traesch lawyer

A The debtor of the eviction indemnity


The debtor of the eviction indemnity is the party who issued the notice without an offer of renewal. Thus, in the event of sale of the building after the notice has been given, the debtor of the indemnity is the former owner.

Unless otherwise agreed in the deed of sale. In the event of dismemberment of ownership, the owner’s purchaser, upon renewal of the commercial lease, is not necessarily jointly and severally liable with the usufructuary skeleton of the eviction indemnity debtor.

B The creditor of the eviction indemnity

The creditor of the eviction indemnity is the lessee or assignee who has acquired the business subsequent to the notice of termination, as the transfer of the business entails the transfer of the eviction indemnity due to the transferor and of the right of the latter to remain on the premises under article L. 145-28 of the French Commercial Code.

C Payment of eviction compensation, a prerequisite for restitution of the premises

The law provides protection for the lessee right up to the last stage of the parties’ relationship. They provide for a protective chronology, authorizing the lessee to hand over the keys to the lessor after payment of the eviction indemnity.

D Payment to the lessee or a receiver


Payment may be made to the evicted lessee or to a receiver. Although payment into the hands of the lessee is the simplest option, it is rare in practice, since guarantees in the hands of the receiver will provide the lessor with guarantees when it comes to obtaining restitution of the premises, which payment into the hands of the lessee does not offer.

E Appointment of a receiver

Agreement or disagreement of the parties. The receiver may be appointed by mutual agreement of the parties or by a judge.

If you have any questions, please contact us using the contact form at the bottom of the page.

Enforcement of payment of eviction indemnity

Exécution du paiement de l'indemnité d'éviction traesch lawyer

II Enforcement of payment of eviction indemnity** A Debtor of eviction indemnity** A Debtor of eviction indemnity** A Debtor of eviction indemnity

**A Debtor of the eviction indemnity** (in French)
1268 The obligation to pay eviction compensation is incumbent on the party who issued the notice to vacate without a proposal for renewal. Thus, if the property is transferred after the notice has been issued, the obligation to pay the indemnity rests with the previous owner (Cass. 3e civ,
April 5, 2011, n° 10-18.241 : JurisData n° 2011-018848; 2011, n° 300, p.
E Chavanac). This obligation may be modified by a stipulation to the contrary in the deed of sale (Cass. 3e civ., 29 nov. 2005, n°
04-17.723; JurisData n° 2005-031059; – Cass. 3e civ., March 5, 2008, n°
06-19.237; JurisData n° 2008-043005; JCP E 2008, 1137, obs. R. Marty).
In the event of dismemberment of ownership, the new buyer is not necessarily jointly and severally liable with the usufructuary of the property for payment of the eviction indemnity (Cass. 3e civ., 16 déc. 2019, n°
18-26.182; Publi.Loyers et copr. 2020, comm. 22, note E. Chavanac; JCP N 2020, 1126, note D.

**B Creditor of the eviction indemnity** (in French)
1269 The beneficiary of the eviction indemnity is the tenant or the transferee who has acquired the business subsequent to the notice.
The transfer of a business entails the transfer of the eviction indemnity due by the assignor, as well as the right to maintain occupancy of the premises under article L. 145-28 of the French Commercial Code (Cass. 3e civ., April 6, 2005, no. 01-12.719; Bull. civ. 2005, III, no. 84).

**C Precondition of payment of eviction indemnity for restitution of premises**.
1270 Sequence of events. Legislation structures tenant protection right up to the terminal phase of the parties’ interactions, establishing a protective sequence authorizing the tenant to return the keys to the lessor after payment of the eviction indemnity.

**D Payment to the evicted tenant or to a receiver** (in French)
1272 Payment may be made either directly to the evicted tenant or to a receiver. Although direct payment to the tenant is the simplest mechanism, it is rarely used in practice, as the use of a receiver offers additional assurances to the lessor for the recovery of the premises, which direct payment does not guarantee.

**E Appointment of a sequestrator**
1273 Agreement or disagreement of the parties. A receiver may be appointed by mutual agreement between the parties or by court order.

Do not hesitate to ask your questions to a lawyer from our firm via the contact form below.

Vacanceole Provence French Leaseback

Eviction of a Tenant under the French Law traesch lawyer
Vacanceole: Provence Eviction of a Tenant

Vacanceole Provence operated a ‘Clos Dia’ tourist residence in Tourrettes

The lessors entered into commercial leases with Vacanceole Provence for the operation of a tourist residence.

Vacanceole Provence: Collective action of 70 owners in French leaseback

A group of 70 lessors seized the property and gave the operator notice to recover their property.

Interim injunction issued by the Draguignan Magistrates’ Court on 9 October 2024

The interim order issued by the Draguignan judicial court on 9 October 2024 in the referenced case concerns a dispute over a commercial lease.

The plaintiffs, various owners of lots located in the ‘Clos Dia’ residence in Tourrettes, entered into commercial leases with the Vacancéole Provence company for the operation of a tourist residence. The agreed rent was 300,000 euros per annum, plus a 40% share of operating profits. The lessors criticised the lessee company for failing to pay certain rents, because the rents were not indexed.

Unpaid rents linked to the failure of Vacanceole Provence to index rents annually

As a result of unpaid rent linked to the failure of the operator of the tourist residence to index the rent each year and the refusal to renew several leases, the owners applied to the interim relief judge to declare the acquisition of the resolutory clause in the lease contracts and order the eviction of the tenant company. They also requested that the company be ordered to pay unpaid rent for the lack of annual indexation.

In its defence, SASU Vacancéole Provence contested the service of the summons to pay and the notice to quit. It raised objections of nullity due to the failure to provide supporting documents. In the alternative, it asked for time to pay and made counterclaims, in particular claiming compensation for eviction.

Dismissal of the application to set aside the notices of termination

The court examined the procedural objections raised by the tenant company. It pointed out that the interim relief judge cannot declare bailiff’s documents null and void, but can only verify whether there are serious disputes. In this case, the summons to pay and the notice to vacate were in fact mentioned in the list of documents, and the tenant company had not demonstrated any grievance caused by this alleged irregularity.

With regard to the substantive claims, the court analysed the provisions of Articles L.145-14 and L.145-28 of the French Commercial Code, which set out the rights of tenants in the event of a refusal to renew a lease and in the event of eviction compensation. The court considered that, on the basis of the evidence presented, an expert appraisal was required to assess the eviction compensation potentially due. Theexpert opinion was therefore ordered, at the advanced expense of the lessors, as is customary.

Application for termination without eviction compensation based on resolutory clauses in the leases

With regard to the termination clauses in the leases, the court referred to the provisions of article L.145-41 of the French Commercial Code. It noted that the payment orders issued were valid, but that the sums claimed did not, in its view, justify a sufficiently precise breakdown. However, a table showing updates by year was appended to the summons to pay issued by the bailiff. It is likely that the interim judge did not intend to take responsibility for terminating certain commercial leases for failure to index the rent annually.

As a result, the claim remained disputable according to the interim relief judge, and the court rejected the applications to acquire the termination clauses (resolutory clauses) and the requested evictions. In addition, the applications for an advance on index-linked rents were also rejected on the grounds that they were seriously disputed.

Vacanceole Provence Counterclaims

Finally, the court rejected Vacanceole Provence’s counterclaims for lack of sufficient evidence. It also ruled that there were no grounds for interim relief in respect of the landlords’ claims.

In conclusion, the court ordered a legal expert to assess the eviction compensation, but rejected the parties’ other claims.

Waiver of the eviction damages in the lease written by the lessee

Vacanceole Provence has chosen to refuse to enforce the waiver of the eviction compensation in the lease written by the former lessee. The owners have agreed to renew the last lease only because this waiver was included in the new lease. Such a bad faith is based on a change of case law of the French high court (Cour de cassation), especially if the waiver is in the lease and not in another document following the lease.

The british press was right to critize the bad faith of the operator (tenant/lessee) of the French leaseback property.

If you have any questions, please contact us using the contact form here.

How to terminate the lease of a leaseback in a tourist residence

How to terminate the lease of a leaseback in a tourist residence traesch lawyer

Notice: how to terminate a commercial lease

1 – Terminate the Lease: Sending the notice to the right people

When given by the lessor, the notice must be sent to the lessee, or to each of them if there are several. If the tenant decides to terminate, he or she must send the notice to the person having the status of lessor; if there are several lessors, the notice sent to one of them takes effect for all the others.

The involvement of a lawyer before this stage ensures that no irregularities are made. An irregular notice will force the owner-lessor to issue a new notice and once again respect the notice period stipulated in the commercial lease. In practice, the notice period specified in the commercial lease ranges from 6 to 12 months.

2 – Terminate the Lease: Sending notice at the right time

In principle, the tenant must send his notice at least six months before the expiry of each three-year period (i.e. at least six months before three years following the conclusion of the lease, then six years, then nine years). Both parties can send notice at the end of the contract, also giving at least six months’ notice.

However, in the case of a lease for a tourist residence, article L.145-7-1 of the French Commercial Code prohibits the tenant from giving notice at the end of a three-year period. In other words, when the operator of a the leaseback property (tourist residence) signs a contract with the lessor, he is committed for at least the first 9 years.

Where notice is given late, its effect is postponed until the last day of the following quarter. Example: the lease for the tourist residence was due to expire on 30/01/2019, and the tenant sent his notice on 15/11/2018; the notice will only take effect on June 31, the last day of the quarter.

If the notice is given too early, it will take effect on the expiry date of the lease or, if it is given during the course of the lease, on the expiry of the next three-year term.

3 – Taking care with the form and content of the notice

Notice of termination from the lessor

Articles L. 145-9 and L. 145-4 of the French Commercial Code require the lessor to deliver the notice to the lessee(s) by bailiff. The notice must contain the following elements :

  • a clear and unambiguous notice to terminate the contract ;
  • a statement that any tenant wishing to contest the notice must take the matter to court within two years of the date of notification;
  • the reason why the lessor is giving notice.

The notice without eviction indemnity must refer to the serious and legitimate reasons already set out in a prior formal notice to the lessee (the operator of the leaseback or tourist residence).

Notice with eviction indemnity does not require a reasoned refusal to renew the commercial lease.

The specialized lawyer can supervise the bailiff’s work on behalf of the lessor to avoid drafting errors (e.g.: notice without eviction indemnity with an erroneous mention such as “sale”).

Notice of termination from the tenant

The operator of a tourist residence who gives notice of termination at the end of the contract (or during tacit extension) can only do so by bailiff’s writ. He is not required to explain the reason for his notice.

Do not hesitate to contact us to ask us your questions via the contact form at the bottom of the homepage.

Unpaid rent: solutions

leaseback traesch lawyer

What should a landlord do about unpaid rent?

Landlords are sometimes faced with what they dread most: a tenant who stops paying rent. This is a major problem, and one that can leave landlords feeling helpless and powerless. What can you do if this happens? What legal remedies are available?

How to recover rent arrears?

The first thing a landlord is interested in is recovering what is owed, i.e. all the payments that have not been made each month. This is called rent arrears.

This shortfall can put the landlord in a delicate financial position, which is why it’s urgent to take action, so that the situation doesn’t drag on.

There are two steps to take:

  • the landlord must issue a summons to pay
  • and, one month later, refer the matter to the interim relief judge to obtain termination of the lease and an order to pay the debt.

Step 1: Order to pay unpaid rent

Two months after having a bailiff issue a summons to pay unpaid rent, the landlord must apply to the district court to have the lease terminated and the tenant evicted.

The tenant then has two months in which to settle the rental debt and the cost of the payment order. If the tenant has not settled his debt within this period, the landlord is then in a position to move on to the second stage: bringing the matter before the magistrate (juge des référés) of the court.

To do this, he or she must instruct a lawyer to draw up a writ of summons before the tribunal. Please note: this summons must be sent to the prefect at least two months before the hearing date, failing which it will be inadmissible.

Let’s take a closer look at this second step…

How do you terminate a lease for unpaid rent?

In addition to simply paying the rent owed, the landlord is interested in terminating the lease and evicting the offending tenant. A complex procedure, the main stages of which can be summarized as follows…

Step 2: The court of first instance to terminate the lease and request eviction

First of all, the landlord applies to the court for termination of the lease and eviction of the tenant.

The tenant can ask for up to 24 months to pay off his debt (article 1244-1 of the French Civil Code).

This repayment of rent arrears is in addition to the payment of rent, which must be resumed.

If the tenant defaults on a single payment, the landlord can begin eviction proceedings without having to go before a judge again.

The judgment (order) must be delivered to the tenant by a bailiff, together with a summons to vacate the premises. The tenant then has two months to vacate the premises.

Please note

evictions are prohibited between November 1 and March 15 (article L613-3 of the French Construction and Housing Code). This is known as the “winter truce”. It is thought that it would be too difficult to find oneself without housing in the middle of winter, in the cold. It is therefore advisable to launch this procedure while ensuring that its progress respects this timetable, so as not to be interrupted by the winter truce.

Conclusion

As you can see, if you’re a homeowner faced with this problem, there is legal recourse available to you. All you have to do is contact us by filling in this form.

Foreigners can benefit from the status of commercial leases

Foreigners can benefit from the status of commercial leases traesch lawyer

Application of commercial leases to foreigners

Loi Plinel

Since the PINEL Act of 2014, foreigners have enjoyed the right to benefit from the status of commercial leases.

Legislative confirmation of case law

The French Supreme Court has ruled out the application of this discriminatory condition (Civ. 3, November 9, 2011, n°10-30.291).

If you have any questions, please contact us using the contact form at the bottom of the page.

Artists and commercial leases

Artists and commercial leases traesch lawyer

Application of the commercial lease statute to protect tenants

The status of commercial leases

A tenant wishes to have his lease reclassified as a commercial lease in order to benefit from the status of commercial leases. In this case, the tenant was an artist, and it is not obvious whether the lease qualifies as a commercial lease.

Artist and entitlement to commercial lease status

A painter obtained the application of the status of commercial leases to his lease, because :

  • he sold paintings on the commercial premises,
  • he was eligible to contribute to the Maison des Artistes security fund,
  • he was recognized as an author of graphic and plastic works of art,

even if the premises and the object of the commercial lease were not registered in the files of the caisse de sécurité de la maison des artistes. Cass. Civ.3, March 23, 2011, n°10-304495

If you have any questions, please contact us using the contact form at the bottom of the page.

Does the former commercial tenant have to pay debts ?

student residence

Can the landlord sue the former commercial tenant? Yes, if there is a joint and several liability clause in the commercial lease, creating a joint and several liability between the former tenant and the new tenant. There is an exception to this rule, even in the absence of a solidarity clause.

If there is no joint and several liability clause in the commercial lease

Conditions for joint and several liability of the former commercial tenant

The Court of Cassation (Cass. civ. 3, 12-07-1988, n˚ 86-15.759) has recalled that :

  • the transfer of the commercial lease is in order,
  • and no Solidarity Clause is stipulated in the lease transfer contract,

then: the landlord cannot claim from the assignor (who has assigned the lease) payment of rents due subsequent to the lease assignment. Clearly, in this case, the former tenant is not required to pay any debts arising after the transfer of the commercial lease.

Exception: the person assigning the lease knew that the assignment was being contested by successive lessors.

If the commercial lessee who assigns his commercial lease could not have been unaware, at the time of the assignment, that the successive lessors were contesting the legality of the lease assignment, then the former lessee must guarantee the debt even in the absence of a non-guarantee clause. (Cass. civ. 3, 24-06-1998, n˚ 96-19.042)

Drafting and understanding the content of a commercial lease is essential

The commercial lease is therefore an advantage for the lessee who assigns his commercial lease, but can be analyzed as a major loophole in the commercial lease contract. Landlords should therefore pay close attention to this point when drafting their commercial lease. In addition, the signature of a personal guarantee by the manager of the lessee company may offer an additional guarantee to the lessor.

Solidarity clause in the commercial lease

Existence of a solidarity clause between the old and new commercial lessees

Whoever transfers his commercial lease with his business will be liable for rent only until the end of a 3-year period since the law of June 20, 2014 (Pinel law).

1-month deadline for informing former tenant of first unpaid rent

Please note that the lessor must inform the former tenant of any unpaid rent within 1 month of the date on which the rent should have been paid. In practice, this rule is very restrictive for the landlord, who often gives the tenant some time to regularize the situation. The landlord must now react immediately in writing, and no longer be content with oral conversations with the tenant and guarantor.

If you have any questions, please contact us using the contact form at the bottom of the page.

Eviction compensation for a tourist hotel

eviction indemnity  Traesch Lawyer

How to calculate eviction indemnity for a tourist hotel ?

The bottom line: judges use the average of 3 methods to calculate eviction compensation

In this case regarding eviction indemnity, the legal expert applied the sales method, the cash flow method and the EBITDA (gross operating profit) method. The court accepted the average of the three results obtained using the three accounting methods (i.e. an average value of €374,225).

Facts

On January 1, 2000, Mrs B. signed a commercial lease with S.A.R.L. Hôtel des Chênes for a property complex including a three-star hotel in PUJOLS, for a period of nine years, i.e. until December 31, 2008. On November 25, 2008, Mrs B. sold the property to SCI Pujols Bel Air, which intervened in the current proceedings. SCI Pujols Bel Air reiterated its refusal to renew the lease and offered to pay an eviction indemnity to be determined by expert appraisal. S.A.R.L. Hôtel des Chênes served SCI Pujols Bel Air with a writ of summons to set the eviction indemnity in accordance with article L415-14 of the French Commercial Code. An expert appraisal was ordered.

Claims of the parties relating to the calculation of eviction compensation

Under the terms of article L 145-17 et seq. of the French Commercial Code, the eviction indemnity includes the market value of the business, determined in accordance with professional practice, plus various expenses. To evaluate the eviction indemnity, Monsieur VIDEAU, as is customary, used three cross-checking methods:

  • the method based on sales according to the usual scales applied by the profession and by the tax authorities (the Lefevre scale and the Blatter scale),
  • the cash flow method,
  • the EBITDA valuation method.

The main eviction indemnity

Under the terms of article L 145-17 et seq. of the French Commercial Code, the eviction indemnity includes in particular the market value of the business, determined in accordance with professional practice.

Accounting methods

S.A.R.L. Hôtel des Chênes firstly criticizes the two methods calculated by Mr. B., i.e. the estimate based on financing capacity and the estimate based on gross operating surplus, on the grounds that these methods are only valid for the valuation of a company and not for the valuation of a business, which is a broader concept with a strong patrimonial and fiscal connotation. However, S.A.R.L. Hôtel des Chênes will be told that the value of a business is not the same as the value of the company operating the business. The valuation of a business cannot be made in abstracto, but must correspond to an economic reality. As the appraiser points out, the potential buyer must have the means to finance the acquisition on the basis of the actual existing business. This is why valuation methods that include financing capacity and EBITDA are essential. The expert rightly points out that when the G. consorts bought the shares in S.A.R.L. Hôtel des Chênes in March 2005, they borrowed €275,000 and contributed €150,000 to the partners’ account: if their valuation method were adopted, the debt would triple, and S.A.R.L. Hôtel des Chênes would immediately be in suspension of payments. As soon as sales fall (which is our case), the value of the business must fall accordingly.

The coefficient used

S. A.R.L. Hôtel des Chênes believes that the usual coefficient for the hotel industry is an average of 2.63, and that the lowest coefficient in the Lot et Garonne region is 2.02. The company is therefore requesting that this coefficient be applied. It therefore requests that this coefficient be applied. The expert retained a coefficient of 1.5. First of all, with regard to the coefficient usually used in the profession, it is inaccurate to say that the average is 2.63. This average is based solely on Blatter and Perbos. The reference works are Blatter and Lefèvre. However, Lefèvre 2007 suggests a valuation of between 0.80 and 3.5 times sales for 3* hotels, while Blatter mentions a coefficient of 2 to 4 times sales for tourist hotels (regardless of category). Perbos mentions a coefficient of 2 to 3.5, with no further explanation. But we don’t ask an expert to apply an average range. He is asked to apply a coefficient appropriate to the situation of the business being appraised. He concludes by pointing out that it would appear random to base a valuation on more than 1.4/1.6 times annual sales. In the light of these factors, it is appropriate to retain the upper range of Monsieur VIDEAU’s reasonable valuation, i.e. a multiplying coefficient of 1.6, which brings the amount of the valuation by sales to €431,963.

The estimate retained for the main indemnity will therefore be calculated as follows:

  • Estimate based on sales: €431,963
  • Estimate based on cash flow: €314,316
  • Estimated gross operating surplus: €376,398

For an average value of : 374.225 €. The first decision will be reversed on this point.

Ancillary indemnities

Re-use costs

As the value of the business is slightly higher than that recommended by the expert, the re-employment costs will be slightly modified as follows:

  • duties on transfers for valuable consideration of business assets :
    0 à 23 000 € = 0 %
    23.000 à 200.000 € : 3 % = 5.310 €
    200.000 à 374.225 € : 5 % = 8.711 €
    Total: €14,021
  • search costs for an equivalent fund:
    374.225 € x 5 % = 18.711 €
    TOTAL re-use costs: €32,732.

Commercial disturbance

This involves compensation for the loss suffered by the evicted tenant during the period of removal and reinstallation, or, in the absence of reinstallation, during the period of cessation of operations. According to the expert, jurisprudence usually sets the compensation at three months’ net income. The expert suggests that the court should increase this indemnity, given that the notice of termination was issued with effect from January 1, 2009, i.e. more than two years ago, and that as a result of this notice of termination the tenant can no longer implement the essential modernization projects. He points out that sales are almost identical to those of 2007. However, S. A.R.L. Hôtel des Chênes has pointed out that sales rose by 13.88% in the first four months of 2011, which would suggest that the eviction procedure has had no impact on the hotel’s business. He therefore proposes to retain an indemnity equivalent to six months’ net income. The first judge retained an indemnity of four months, closer to the average indemnity, but taking into account the long period that had elapsed since the date of notice. His assessment will be retained and his decision confirmed on this point. The other heads of compensation are accepted by both parties.

Amounts of damages constituting the eviction indemnity

The Court:

  • Fixes the principal indemnity at €374,225,
  • Fixes the re-employment indemnity at €32,732,
  • Commercial disturbance: €10,255
  • Staff redundancy costs: €3,580
  • Unamortized works and improvements: €16,011
  • Administrative and miscellaneous costs: €10,000

Consequently, orders SCI Pujols Bel Air to pay S.A.R.L. Hôtel des Chênes the sum of €446,803 as eviction compensation. CA Agen April 24, 2013 n° 12/01276 , ch. civile

Eviction compensation: the judges against the expert

Eviction compensation the judges against the expert traesch lawyer

Judges sometimes review and modify the expert’s calculations

Summary

The court uses the sales method instead of EBITDA. Only the accounts certified by the chartered accountant are taken into account in determining the amount of the eviction indemnity. The judges rejected the appraiser’s assessment of potential revenue after renovation work had not been carried out.

Hotel, Sales method. Total eviction compensation: €1,459,535 + €163,238 = €1,622,773

Calculating eviction compensation

Sales instead of EBITDA method

The low profitability of the business, which has only 16 rooms after renovation work, means that the gross operating surplus method of valuing the business should not be used. In this case, the judges opted for the sales-based method.

Only the accounts certified by the chartered accountant are taken into account.

The lessee company asked that the sales figures for 2011, 2012 and 2013 be taken into account, on the grounds that the eviction indemnity should be assessed at the date closest to the eviction, while the B. consorts pointed out that the accounting results for 2012 and 2013 had not been certified by the company’s chartered accountant. Relais Hôtel Esmeralda counters that the certificate issued by the company’s chartered accountant includes the sales figures shown in the accounting documents for both 2012 and 2013. The judges rejected the draft accounts, retaining only the sales figures for the years certified by the chartered accountant.

Judges reject expert’s assessment of potential revenue after renovation work not carried out

The court rightly rejected the appraiser’s approach, which consisted in assessing potential revenue taking into account the renovation work carried out on the premises, Relais Hôtel Esmeralda asked that this approach be retained, since it takes into account a probable but not certain renovation hypothesis, which in any case has not been carried out by the lessee, and consequently cannot be taken into account when assessing the hotel’s current value, unless this potentiality is taken into account at the same time as the excellence of the location when assessing the multiplier coefficient.

The multiplying factor usually used for 1-star hotel transactions varies from 3.5 to 4 times the average sales figure, depending on the expert; given the hotel‘s excellent location and renovation potential, a factor of 3.5 should be used, so that the main indemnity is set at : 417 010 € x 3, 5 = 1 459 535 €

Ancillary indemnities

Replacement costs

The rate of 10% applied to reinvestment costs is not seriously contested, as the B. consorts are asking that a rate of 8% be retained in the event of a renegotiation of the rate, given the amount involved in the transaction; however, this is a random element which cannot form the basis of a calculation, so that reinvestment costs will be retained at €145,953.

Disturbance of trade and social costs

The amounts of compensation for commercial disruption and social costs as retained by the court are not contested and will be confirmed. Relais Hôtel Esmeralda also seeks compensation for the portion of unamortized investments it is abandoning, in the amount of €267,001, without claiming relocation costs as such, which in any case would not be equivalent to the unamortized investments, so this claim will be rejected. Redundancy costs will be paid on the basis of receipts.

Total eviction compensation

The total eviction compensation therefore amounts to : 1 459 535 € + 163 238 = 1 622 773 €. COUR D’APPEL Paris June 11, 2014 n° 12/13816 , Pôle 05 ch. 03

If you have any questions, please contact us using the contact form at the bottom of the page.

ASK YOUR QUESTION (FREE) - RESPONSE WITHIN A BUSINESS DAY

We will respond to all e-mail contacts within a business day. We Make French Law Understandable. The answer to your question will be written only by a partner of our law firm.