Post-purchase discovery of hotel residence destination

Post-purchase discovery of hotel residence destination traech lawyer

On January 30, 2024, the Versailles judicial court handed down a judgment concerning a real estate dispute involving Mrs [Aa] [N], SCI BTX, several notaries, a real estate agency (CPH IMMOBILIER), and the syndic ASL GESTION. Mrs [Aa] [N] had bought a studio apartment with parking in 2016, believing it to be for residential use, but subsequently discovered that it was part of a hotel residence, resulting in unforeseen hotel charges.

Legal action for fraud seeking annulment of the sale

Mrs [Aa] [N] brought an action for fraud, seeking annulment of the sale, restitution of the purchase price and damages. She accused SCI BTX of concealing from her the true nature of the property and the associated charges. SCI BTX, the notaries and the estate agent disputed these accusations, claiming to have provided all the necessary information.

Sufficient information but lack of professional advice

The court examined the documents provided at the time of sale, including the co-ownership regulations and the minutes of the general meetings, which clearly indicated the property’s status as a hotel residence. The court concluded that Mrs [Aa] [N] had received sufficient information to understand the situation of the property, but that the notaries had failed in their duty to advise her by not fully informing her of the legal and financial implications of the purchase.

The court dismissed Mrs [Aa] [N]’s claims against SCI BTX and ASL GESTION, but ordered the notaires and the estate agency to pay her 8,855.60 euros in damages, 80% to the notaires and 20% to the estate agency. The court also ordered provisional execution of the decision.

Notary and real estate agency fines

Breach of duty to advise

In summary, the court recognized that Mrs. [Aa] [N] had been partially informed, but that the notaries had failed in their duty to advise, resulting in a loss of opportunity for her to abandon the purchase of a hotel residence. The notaries and the real estate agency were ordered to pay damages to compensate for this loss.

Ask your questions using the contact form at the bottom of the page.

Brokerage: Abrupt termination of the business relationship

Brokerage Abrupt termination of the business relationship traesch lawyer

In this ruling handed down by the Commercial Chamber of the French Supreme Court on January 31, 2024 (appeal no. 22-24.045), the Court dismisses the main and cross-appeals lodged respectively by Cofape International and Soletanche Bachy France. The dispute concerns the alleged brutal severance of the commercial relationship between the two companies, which were involved in brokerage and insurance policy management.

Brokerage and insurance policies

Commercial relations

Soletanche Bachy had a commercial relationship with Cofape, which managed insurance policies on its behalf and also acted as a broker.

On December 14, 2017, Cofape informed Soletanche Bachy that it was entrusting the management of its group health and provident insurance policies to another company as of January 2018.

In June 2018, Soletanche Bachy appointed a new broker, the company Verlingue, to take over the study and management of its insurance policies, thus terminating the relationship with Cofape. In October 2018, Soletanche Bachy terminated its provident and supplementary health plans with the company GAN, with which Cofape was collaborating.

The notice period in this brokerage case

In March 2019, Cofape sued Soletanche Bachy for damages for the brutal termination of its commercial relationship, arguing that it had not been given sufficient notice given the length of their relationship.

Cofape criticized the Court of Appeal for rejecting its claim for damages, despite a drop in its commissions and sales after the termination. Soletanche Bachy argued that it had suffered moral prejudice as a result of Cofape’s abrupt termination of its insurance brokerage contract management mission, and claimed damages.

The Court’s response

The Court also rejected this argument. In its view, the malfunctions alleged by Soletanche Bachy at the time of the change of manager did not constitute a loss that could be compensated on the basis of sudden termination.

Sufficient notice period and absence of economic dependence

The French Supreme Court confirms the decision of the Paris Court of Appeal. The notice period granted to Cofape was sufficient and appropriate to the nature of the commercial relationship between the parties. Cofape was unable to prove a state of economic dependence on Soletanche Bachy.

No moral prejudice

Soletanche Bachy cannot obtain compensation for non-material damage linked to malfunctions in the transition of insurance policy management. Consequently, the appeals are dismissed, and the parties are left to bear their own costs.

https://frenchleasebacklawyer.com/Ask your questions using the contact form at the bottom of the page.

Deflating the rent: authorization to operate a terrace

Deflating the rent authorization to operate a terrace traech lawyer

Landlords plead significant modification of local commercial factors

Municipal authorization to operate a terrace

Summary: The July 4, 2024 ruling by the French Supreme Court (no. 23-13.515) confirms the rejection of a request to de-cap the rent on a commercial lease. The lessors claimed a significant change in local commercial factors due to a municipal authorization to operate a terrace. The Court ruled that the terrace had already existed under the previous operators, thus rejecting the argument of significant change. This ruling is a reminder of the strict requirement of proof to justify a change in the rent ceiling.

1 Facts and procedure

The judgment under appeal, handed down by the Dijon Court of Appeal on December 1, 2022, concerns a dispute between the lessors, Mrs [M] [C] and Messrs [W] and [U] [C] (acting as bare owners), and the Lauman company, lessee under a commercial lease for a restaurant-bar-brasserie.

At the end of the initial lease signed on November 1, 2002, the parties proceeded to renew the lease with effect from November 1, 2011, with the landlords requesting that the rent be set at a reduced rate on the grounds of a significant change in local market factors. This request was based on the tenant’s obtaining a municipal permit to operate a 93 m² terrace on the public domain.

Believing that this change justified an increase in the rent, the landlords took the matter to court. The Dijon Court of Appeal rejected their request, a decision against which they appealed to the French Supreme Court.

2. The landlords’ arguments

The lessors put forward two main arguments:

a) The existence of a significant change in local commercial factors

They argued that the municipal authorization granted in 2005 to operate a 93 m² terrace constituted a significant change in the operating conditions of the business, leading to an increase in the value of the goodwill and thus justifying a rent review outside the limits of the legal ceiling.

They argued that this terrace represented a significant increase in the surface area available for the operation of the restaurant, especially as the municipal fee was low.

b) The Court of Appeal’s error of assessment as to the existence of a significant modification

The landlords criticized the ruling for relying on a statement by a former waitress to the effect that the terrace already existed before the lease expired, and that it extended right up to the steps of a church.

They felt that this attestation was insufficient to reject their argument, in the absence of precise information on the actual extent of the terrace prior to 2005.

They considered that the Court of Appeal had not correctly drawn the legal conclusions from its own findings.

The Cour de cassation’s response

The Cour de cassation dismissed the appeal, recalling the following principles:

1) The principle of capping commercial rents and its exceptions

In accordance with articles L. 145-33 and L. 145-34 of the French Commercial Code, the rent for a renewed lease is, in principle, capped unless a significant change in the factors used to calculate rental value can be demonstrated. These factors include, in particular, local market factors.

The burden of proof lies with the lessor requesting the removal of the ceiling.

2) Sovereign appraisal by trial judges

The Court reiterated that the assessment of whether the modification is significant is a matter for the trial judges to decide.

The Court of Appeal rightly examined whether the extension of the terrace in 2005 constituted a significant change in local commercial factors.

It noted that, prior to 2005, Lauman already had a large terrace, extending right up to the church steps, which contradicts the claim that the 2005 municipal authorization created a significant break in the operation of the business.

3) Absence of proof of a significant change

The appeal court noted that the authorization to operate the terrace granted in 2005 did not constitute a significant change, since the terrace already existed under the previous operators.

Consequently, it rightly deduced that the conditions for de-capping had not been met.

Solution of the French Supreme Court

The appeal is dismissed.

The lessors are ordered to pay the costs.

Their claims under article 700 of the French Code of Civil Procedure are rejected.

This ruling illustrates the strict evidentiary requirements imposed on landlords who invoke a significant change in local commercial factors to request a rent adjustment.

Three main conclusions can be drawn from it:

  1. Municipal authorization to operate a terrace on the public domain can be a factor in raising the rent, but only if it leads to a real change in the operating conditions of the business.
  2. The prior existence of a terrace operated by the lessee or his predecessors may neutralize the lessor’s argument in favor of de-capping.
  3. The Cour de cassation does not go back on the sovereign assessment of the lower courts, except in cases of manifest error or lack of legal basis.

Thus, in order to obtain a de-capping of the commercial rent, lessors must provide indisputable proof of a significant change in the commercial environment of the premises. In this case, such proof was not deemed sufficient, and the appeal was dismissed.

Full text

Facts and procedure

1. According to the judgment under appeal (Dijon, December 1, 2022), handed down on referral from the French Supreme Court (3rd Civ., October 13, 2021, appeal no. 20-12.901, published), Mrs [M] [C] and Messrs [W] and [U] [C] (the lessors) agreed, with effect from November 1, 2011, to the renewal of the commercial lease held by Lauman (the lessee), a restaurant-bar-brasserie operator, in return for the setting of a rent with a reduced ceiling.

2. They then summoned the tenant to fix the rent for the renewed lease at the rental value.

Examination of the plea

The third and fourth grounds of appeal

3. Pursuant to article 1014, paragraph 2, of the Code of Civil Procedure, there is no need to issue a specially reasoned decision on these complaints, which are clearly not such as to lead to cassation.

First and second grounds of appeal

Statement of the plea

4. The lessors object to the decision rejecting their request for the setting of an uncapped rent, on the grounds that:

“1°/ that a municipal authorization allowing a restaurant-bar-brasserie to extend its terrace onto the public domain is likely to constitute a significant change in local commercial factors, and therefore a significant change in the rent.

local commercial factors, and therefore grounds for removing the ceiling on the rent increase for the lease of which the restaurant owner is the lessee; that in the case in point, after having noted that it was common ground that during the expired lease, Lauman had obtained from the commune of [Locality 4] an authorization to occupy the public domain, issued on May 19, 2005, corresponding to a terrace with a surface area of 93 m² which, according to the legal expert, could be considered exceptional both in terms of its surface area and the low price of the fees paid, and that the Lauman company did not provide proof of any prior written authorization from the municipality for the operation of such a terrace, the appeal court could not then assert that there was no reason to adjust the rent in the absence of any change in local commercial factors, on the pretext that a statement by a former waitress (Mrs. [H]) employed in 2003-2004 in the establishments that preceded the one operated by the Lauman company indicated that they had a terrace “extending right up to the church steps [5]”, which was insufficient to establish that the extension of the terrace’s surface area during the expired lease was limited to a mere 15 m², in the absence of any reference to an objective element specifying this surface area, which would enable the judge to verify it, to ascertain the surface area in square meters occupied by the terrace of these establishments and to compare it with the existing one; that in so ruling, the Court of Appeal failed to enable the Cour de cassation to exercise its review powers, thereby depriving its decision of a legal basis under articles L. 145-33, L. 145-34 and R. 145-6 of the French Commercial Code;

2°/ that a significant change in local commercial factors gives rise to a right to de-cap the rent of the renewed lease when it occurs during the term of the expired lease; it is common ground that the expired lease took effect on November 1, 2002, and it follows from the judgment’s own findings that Mrs [H]’s attestation that the terrace extended right up to the steps of the church [5] concerned the period from 2003 onwards, i.e. the period covered by the disputed lease; that in asserting that the lessee benefited “prior to the expired lease” from a large terrace extending as far as the church steps [5] in order to rule out the existence of a significant extension of the terrace, and consequently a significant change in the local commercial factors, during the expired lease, the appeal court failed to draw the legal conclusions from its own findings and thus violated articles L. 145-33, L. 145-34 and R. 145-6 of the French Commercial Code.

The Court’s response

5. Pursuant to articles L. 145-33 and L. 145-34 of the French Commercial Code, it is up to the lessor, when applying for the de-capping of the price of the renewed lease, to establish the existence, during the course of the lease to be renewed, of a significant change in the elements used to calculate the rental value mentioned in 1° to 4° of article L. 145-33.

6. Whether or not the change is significant is a matter for the court to decide.

7. The Court of Appeal first rightly held that a municipal authorization to extend the operation of a terrace onto the public domain contributed to the development of commercial activity, so that it was necessary to investigate whether this situation could have modified the local commercial factors constituting grounds for de-capping.

8. It then noted that the lessee had obtained from the municipality of [Locality 4] an authorization to occupy the public domain, issued on May 19, 2005, corresponding to a terrace with a surface area of 93 m², divided into a part in line with the establishment and a part against the church [5], and that although the lessee did not provide proof of any previous written authorization from the municipality for the operation of such a terrace, and in particular of a surface area of 71 m² between 1989 and 1999, increased to 79 m² between 1999 and 2005, the testimony of a former waitress employed by the previous operators between 2003 and 2004 showed that these establishments had a terrace extending right up to the church steps [5], which contradicted the landlords’ contention that the terrace between 1989 and 2005 consisted only of a few tables and chairs located under an awning in front of the commercial premises.

9. The Court therefore found that the tenant, who had enjoyed a large terrace prior to the expired lease, had not benefited from a significant extension of the terrace in 2005, and deduced that, since the lessors had not provided evidence of a significant change in the local commercial factors, the claim for the setting of a price below the ceiling had to be rejected.

10. The plea is therefore unfounded.

FOR THESE REASONS, the Court :

DISMISSES the appeal;

Order Mrs [M] [C] and Messrs [W] and [U] [C] to pay the costs;

In application of article 700 of the French Code of Civil Procedure, dismisses the claims; Thus made and judged by the Court of Cassation, Third Civil Division, and delivered by the President at its public hearing on July 4, 2004.ECLI:FR:CCASS:2024:C300392

Ask your questions using the contact form at the bottom of the page.

Breach of commercial relations (accounting)

Breach of commercial relations (accounting) traesch lawyer

Compensation for sudden termination of an established commercial relationship

Termination of a service contract

In this ruling handed down by the Commercial Chamber of the French Supreme Court on September 4, 2024 (appeal no. 23-10.446), the Court dismisses the appeal lodged by GRG against a ruling by the Paris Court of Appeal dated October 5, 2022. Mecarungis had sued GRG for damages for the brutal breach of an established commercial relationship following the termination of a service contract.

Key points of the ruling

Termination of an accounting services contract

GRG, a partner and client of Mecarungis, had terminated a contractual relationship for the provision of services, which led Mecarungis to claim damages for the brutal termination of an established commercial relationship.

The monopoly of chartered accountants

GRG argued that Mecarungis’s business constituted a service falling within the monopoly of chartered accountants and that, consequently, the rules governing the sudden termination of commercial relations could not be applied.

GRG also argued that the contractual relations between Mecarungis and its members, the company’s shareholders, should not be subject to the rules on the sudden termination of established commercial relations.

The activity does not fall within the remit of a chartered accountant

On the first point, the Cour de cassation confirmed that Mecarungis’ activity did not fall within the scope of a chartered accountant within the meaning of Ordinance no. 45-2138 of September 19, 1945. In fact, Mecarungis confined itself to managing the central fund and monitoring invoicing on behalf of its members, without carrying out a full accounting or auditing assignment.

The rules governing sudden termination of established commercial relations apply even between shareholders.

On the second plea, the Court ruled that the rules governing the sudden termination of established commercial relations applied, since the relationship between GRG and Mecarungis concerned the provision of services, irrespective of the fact that GRG was a shareholder in Mecarungis.

Conclusion

The French Supreme Court rejected GRG’s appeal, confirming the decision of the Court of Appeal, and ordered GRG to pay Mecarungis 202,700 euros in damages, plus 3,000 euros under article 700 of the French Code of Civil Procedure.

This ruling reaffirms the principle that the rules governing the abrupt termination of established commercial relations can be applied even between companies with capital ties, as long as the commercial relationship is based on the provision of a service.

Ask your questions using the contact form at the bottom of the page.

Goelia Gestion Résidence Cap Bleu

Goelia Gestion Résidence Cap Bleu traesch-avocat

Litigation Cap Bleu tourism residence operated by Goelia Gestion

Tourist residence in Martigues

On November 19, 2020, the Aix-en-Provence Court of Appeal handed down a ruling concerning a dispute between the Syndicat des copropriétaires de la Résidence Cap Bleu and SARL Goelia Gestion and SARL Cabinet Strozzi. The tourist residence, located in Martigues, had a swimming pool whose waterproofing was ensured by a liner. After Rhode Tourisme went into receivership, Goelia Gestion took over management of the residence in June 2013. Goelia Gestion operates on the basis of commercial leases signed with the owners. Urgent work was carried out by A+ Piscines to repair the swimming pool, partly financed by Goelia Gestion.

The Syndicat des copropriétaires disputed the quality of the work and refused to pay the balance to Goelia Gestion.

The Syndicat des copropriétaires disputed the quality of the work and refused to pay the balance due to Goelia Gestion. As a result, Goelia Gestion sued the Syndicat for payment of €12,000, plus damages. The Tribunal de Grande Instance d’Aix-en-Provence ordered the Syndicat to pay this sum, as well as irreducible costs, but dismissed the Syndicat’s warranty claim against Cabinet Strozzi.

Faulty management of the swimming pool works

The Syndicat appealed, accusing Cabinet Strozzi of faults in the management of the pool works, in particular for failing to check the insurance cover of the A+ Piscines company and for failing to take delivery of the works. The Court of Appeal confirmed that Cabinet Strozzi was not responsible for the choice of contractor or the defects, as the management of the pool had been delegated to Goelia Gestion. The Court also rejected the Syndicat’s other claims, including those concerning escrowed sums and unjustified debts.

However, the Court recalculated the administrative fees invoiced by Cabinet Strozzi, fixing them at €2,259.72 instead of €1,958.74, and ordered the Cabinet to reimburse this sum to the Syndicat. The Court dismissed the Syndicat’s claims for damages for loss of cash flow and compensation under article 700 of the French Code of Civil Procedure. Cabinet Strozzi was ordered to pay the costs of the appeal proceedings. 

Ask your questions using the contact form at the bottom of the page.

Adagio Avignon Gare tourist residence

Adagio Avignon Gare tourist residence traesch lawyer

Adagio Avignon Gare: PV-CP City condemned again

On October 26, 2022, the Nîmes Court of Appeal handed down a ruling confirming the Avignon Magistrates’ Court’s judgment of March 24, 2022 concerning a dispute between the PV-CP City company and several co-owners of the tourist residence located at address 80. PV-CP City, the lessee of the commercial leases, had stopped paying rent from March 2020 due to the Covid-19 pandemic and administrative restrictions. In June 2020, after the restrictions had been lifted, PV-CP City had proposed an amendment to the lessors to partially compensate for the unpaid rents, but only nine landlords had accepted.

Judicial termination of leases and eviction of PV CP CITY

The landlords took PV-CP City to court to obtain judicial termination of the leases, eviction of the company, and payment of unpaid rents and compensation. The Avignon Court of First Instance terminated the leases, ordered PV-CP City’s eviction, and ordered the company to pay unpaid rent, occupancy indemnities and damages for moral prejudice.

PV-CP City appealed, arguing that it was impossible to operate the premises due to sanitary restrictions, and requesting the suspension of rents for the periods concerned. The company also contested the nullity of the “Covid” endorsements on the grounds of fraud, and asked for extended payment terms in view of its financial difficulties.

The Court of Appeal rejected PV-CP City’s arguments, confirming that the sanitary restrictions did not constitute a partial loss of the leased property within the meaning of article 1722 of the French Civil Code, and that the lessors had not breached their obligation to deliver. The Court also rejected the request for payment deadlines, noting that PV-CP City had not justified its financial situation and had already benefited from payment deadlines.

Court confirms judicial termination

The Court confirmed the judicial termination of the leases and the eviction of PV-CP City, as well as the company’s order to pay unpaid rent, occupancy indemnities and damages for moral prejudice. The Court also ordered PV-CP City to pay the costs of the proceedings and an additional sum of 300 euros to each of the lessors under article 700 of the French Code of Civil Procedure.

In conclusion, the Nîmes Court of Appeal upheld the judgment of the Avignon Magistrates’ Court, rejecting PV-CP City ‘s arguments and ordering termination of the commercial leases, eviction of the company, and payment of the sums due to the lessors.

CA Nîmes, 26-10-2022 n° 22/01266 Confirmation

Ask your questions using the contact form at the bottom of the page.

Residathenes hotel residence

Residathenes hotel residence traesch lawyer

Dispute between Residathenes and several co-owner-lessors

The judgment handed down by the Paris judicial court on October 8, 2024 concerns a dispute between Residathenes and several co-owner-lessors. Residathenes, which took over the rights of R.B.L. in 2010, operates premises used as a hotel residence.

Orders to pay rent arrears and respect the purpose of the leases

The co-owner-landlords issued summonses to pay rent arrears and to respect the destination of the leases, invoking the resolutory clause.

Residathenes operates a hotel instead of a hotel residence

The landlords went to court to have the leases terminated for non-payment of rent and change of use of the premises, claiming that Residathenes was operating a hotel instead of a hotel residence. Residathenes requested payment terms and suspension of the effects of the resolutory clause, arguing that it had paid the arrears within the time limits set by the summary orders.

The court rejected the landlords’ request to acquire the resolutory clause for non-payment of rent, noting that Residathenes had paid the arrears on time.

Termination of the lease by acquisition of the resolutory clause (operation of a hotel instead of a hotel residence)

However, he noted that the resolutory clause had been acquired for non-compliance with the purpose of the leases, establishing that Residathenes was operating the premises as a hotel, in violation of the terms of the leases, which stipulated operation as a hotel residence.

Eviction of Residathenes

The court ordered the eviction of Residathenes and all its occupants from the premises located at [Address 4] at [Location 37], within two months of service of the judgment. It also ordered Residathenes to pay an occupancy indemnity corresponding to the amount of the last rent in force, plus charges, until the premises are effectively vacated.

830,418 euros in occupancy indemnity arrears

In addition, Residathenes was ordered to pay the co-owner-lessors a total of 830,418 euros in occupancy indemnity arrears, with interest at the legal rate from June 3, 2022, broken down between the various co-owners. The court rejected Residathenes ‘ request to defer payment of its debt, ruling that the company had not demonstrated any recent financial difficulties or good faith.

Finally, Residathenes was ordered to pay each of the co-owners the sum of 3,000 euros under article 700 of the French Code of Civil Procedure, and to pay the costs of the proceedings, including the costs of the summons to pay. The court ordered provisional execution of the judgment, given the age of the dispute. 

Ask your questions using the contact form at the bottom of the page.

Citadines Residence Commercial Rents Judge

Citadines Residence Commercial Rents Judge traesch lawyer

Citadines and Vila Luca dispute over new commercial rents

Setting commercial rents for two apartments in a tourist residence

The judgment handed down by the Paris judicial court on March 14, 2024 concerns a dispute between SA Citadines (plaintiff) and SARL Vila Luca (defendant) over the setting of commercial rents for two apartments in a tourist residence.

Initial leases signed with SNC PV Prog

The initial leases, signed on October 1, 2008 between SNC PV Prog and SA Citadines, were tacitly extended after their expiry on September 30, 2018. SA Citadines requested renewal of the leases from July 1, 2019 with reduced rents, but received no response from SARL Vila Luca.

Citadines referred the matter to the Rent Tribunal.

SA Citadines then sought to have the rents judicially fixed at amounts lower than those initially agreed, on the basis of a rental value assessment carried out by an expert. SARL Vila Luca did not set up a lawyer and did not appear at the hearings. The court ordered the proceedings to be reopened so that SA Citadines could prove that SARL Vila Luca was the lessor, which it attempted to do by producing a seizure report.

Citadines did not prove that Vila Luca was the successor to the PIERRE ET VACANCES group company SNC PV Prog.

However, the court ruled that the evidence provided by SA Citadines was insufficient to establish that SARL Vila Luca had succeeded to the rights of SNC PV Prog as lessor of the two apartments. Consequently, SA Citadines’ claims were dismissed, and it was ordered to pay the costs.

The judgment underlines the importance of providing clear and sufficient evidence to establish lessor status in commercial rental disputes.

TJ de Paris, Loyers commerciaux, 14-03-2024, n° 23/00542

Ask your questions using the contact form at the bottom of the page.

Hotel residence and new rent

Hotel residence and new rent traesch lawyer

A hotel residence

The judge of commercial rents

On January 24, 2024, the Rennes Court of Appeal handed down a ruling concerning a dispute between SARL Résidence Reine Marine and the couple [N] over the renewal of a commercial lease for an apartment. Résidence Reine Marine, which operates a hotel residence, had asked for the annual rent to be reduced to 7,874 euros exclusive of tax, which the couple [N] had refused. The commercial rents judge set the rent at 13,300 euros excl. tax per year from July 1, 2016, a decision contested by Résidence Reine Marine.

Résidence Reine Marine lodged an appeal, requesting that the rent be set at 7,400 euros excluding VAT per year, or failing that, that a new expert be appointed. It put forward a number of arguments, including inconsistencies in the legal expert’s report, an occupancy rate of 58.55% instead of 60%, and a levy rate of 25% instead of 32.5%. She also pointed out the property’s geographical isolation and high operating costs.

The couple [N] asked for the initial judgment to be confirmed, arguing that the residence’s seafront location and numerous services justified the rent set. They also contested the amicable appraisal presented by Résidence Reine Marine.

60% occupancy rate

The Court of Appeal confirmed that a hotel residence is a single-use property, and that the rent must be determined in accordance with hotel industry practices. It applied an average sales figure of 1,764,424 euros and an occupancy rate of 60%.

A 32.5% revenue or effort rate

The 32.5% levy rate was deemed appropriate, taking into account the services offered and the quality of the hotel residence.

A 10% surcharge for work carried out by lessors

The Court also took into account the obligations of lessors, notably major repairs and replacement of furniture, as well as property tax and a fixed charge of 8 euros per m² for co-ownership expenses. It corrected the rent by applying a 10% mark-up for work to be carried out by the lessors.

A rent of 13,171.17 euros excluding VAT

In conclusion, the Court set the rent at 13,171.17 euros excl. VAT per annum from July 1, 2016, partially overturning the initial judgment. Résidence Reine Marine’s claims were dismissed, and the company was ordered to pay the couple [N] 3,000 euros under article 700 of the French Code of Civil Procedure, as well as the costs of the appeal. The parties will be required to draw up a new lease within one month of the judgment being served, failing which the judgment will become the lease. 

Ask your questions using the contact form at the bottom of the page.

Rent Review: Local marketing factors

Rent Review Local marketing factors traesch lawyer

Disagreement over the amount of rent for a renewed lease

This case concerns a dispute between Mr [K] [V] and Mrs [T] [M], wife [V], lessors, and SARL Boucherie Normande, lessee, over the renewal of a commercial lease. The initial lease, signed on July 8, 2010, covered commercial and residential premises located at [Location 1], for an annual rent of 23,449.68 euros. In 2019, the lessee requested renewal of the lease on the same terms, but the lessors proposed an increase in the rent to 37,790 euros, which led to a disagreement.

The landlords then referred the matter to the rent judge of the Lisieux judicial court, who provisionally set the rent at 30,000 euros excluding charges, and ordered a legal appraisal. On June 10, 2022, the judge set the annual rent at 26,882.80 euros, rejected the lessors’ request for an expert appraisal and ordered them to reimburse the excess rent received since July 1, 2019, as well as to pay 4,000 euros in procedural indemnities to the lessee.

Request for further expert appraisal rejected

The lessors lodged an appeal, requesting additional expert appraisal to analyze changes in the lessee’s sales and an increase in rent to 41,162 euros. After examining the arguments and the expert reports, the Caen Court of Appeal upheld the lower court’s judgment. It rejected the request for further expert appraisal, deeming that the accounting documents produced made it possible to rule on the dispute.

Rejection of the request to de-cap the rent

The court also upheld the annual rent of 26,882.80 euros, basing its decision on the characteristics of the premises, the use to which the premises were put, the obligations of the parties, local commercial factors and prices in the vicinity. It ruled that there had been no significant change in local market factors to justify an increase in the rent.

Lastly, the court ordered the lessors to pay the costs of the appeal and 3,000 euros to the lessee under article 700 of the French Code of Civil Procedure, rejecting their claim for procedural damages.

CA Caen, 15-02-2024, n° 22/01824

Ask your questions using the contact form at the bottom of the page.

ASK YOUR QUESTION (FREE) - RESPONSE WITHIN A BUSINESS DAY

We will respond to all e-mail contacts within a business day. We Make French Law Understandable. The answer to your question will be written only by a partner of our law firm.